Full cast (93)
Natasha Leggero
Lillian Abigail Hitler Schmemmerhorn-Fish
Riki Lindhome
Beatrice Tiffani Amber Thiessen Downsy
Paget Brewster
Dodo Bellacourt
Jason Ritter
Frederick Bellacourt
Brian Huskey
Victor Schmemmerhorn-Fish V
David Wain
Albert Downsy, Jr.
David Koechner
The Commodore
Michael Ian Black
Peepers
Armen Weitzman
Garfield
Christina Hendricks
Celine aka Chair
Beth Dover
Blanche
Brett Gelman
Hamish
Lauren Ash
Hortense Jefferson Library Bellacourt
Jon Daly
Officer Kerttrussel O'Kelly
Will Sasso
Officer O'Connor
Alice Hunter
Flobelle
Lou Diamond Phillips
Langundo
Jack Black
Dan Ringley
Ben Stiller
Charles Ponzi
Paxton Booth
Boy on Cemetery Tour
Tim Heidecker
Hal Carnegie
Artemis Pebdani
Hortense Bellacourt
Jessica Chaffin
Pussy Von Andersteen
Moshe Kasher
Dr. Goldberg
Chris Parnell
Dr. Sigmund Freudas
Brian J. White
Chauncey Alistair
Stephen Tobolowsky
Thomas Edison
Ravi Patel
Mohandas Gandhi
Roni Akurati
Tabu
Brent Weinbach
Scoops LaPue
Matt Besser
Leon Trotsky
Josh Fadem
Falling Charlie
Rick Overton
Mr. Savoy
Lauren Lapkus
Penelope
Thomas Barbusca
Jay Densmith
James Herda
Hollingsworth Vanderbilt
Nick Kocher
Vanderbilt #2
Aasif Mandvi
Parshwall
Rizwan Manji
Prince Apato
Rich Fulcher
Mark Twain
Ron Funches
Hamish's Cellmate
Andy Daly
Charlton Wimbledon
Ian Edwards
Black Confessor
Pam Murphy
Martha
Kate Flannery
Anne Sullivan / Annie Sullivan
June Diane Raphael
Eleanor Roosevelt
Michael Welch
Franklin D. Roosevelt
Perez Hilton
Brussels Sheraton
Kurt Braunohler
Dick Firestone
Alison Fernández
Ethanney
Ryan Caltagirone
Sterling
Matt Gourley
Albert Einstein
Karen Kilgariff
Abortion Deb
Adam Pally
Virgil
Gil Ozeri
Harry Houdini / Waiter
Moses Storm
Strom
Joss Whedon
Duane Reade
Michaela Watkins
Brothel Madam
Cedric the Entertainer
Scott Joplin
Billy Merritt
William Howard Taft
Orson Bean
Laverne Fusselforth V
Samm Levine
Chadwick / Men's Club Member
John Ennis
Hobo
Lauren Flans
Bebe Drake
Harriet Tubman
Daryl J. Johnson
Gayle
Andrew Rannells
Bertram Harrison Fusselforth VII
Brendon Walsh
Bartender
Kate Micucci
Eunice
Jemaine Clement
Father Black Donahue
Missi Pyle
Celery Savoy Bellacourt / Celery Savoy
Thomas Lennon
Marquis de Sainsbury
Shoshannah Stern
Helen Keller
Erik Charles Nielsen
John John
Emma Breeze
Adolf Hitler
Amy Hayes
Goody Vanderschmidt
Amanda Lund
Elisabeth Ossett
Rory Scovel
Men's Club Member
Betsy Sodaro
Rachel Blanchard
Endive Savoy
Nancy Friedrich
Cornetta
Owen Burke
Dodo Bird Hunter
Allan McLeod
Paul F. Tompkins
Cole Bottoms
Joe Wengert
Ryan Devlin
Cameraman
Paul Scheer
Pablo Picasso
Jimmy O. Yang
Ang
Mike O'Connell
Teddy Roosevelt
Donna Lynne Champlin
Fortune Feimster
Garva
Audrey Douglass
Dancer
Steve Little
Colonel Beauregard Trimbald