Full cast (170)
Hank Azaria
Jim Brockmire
Tawny Newsome
Gabby Taylor
Tyrel Jackson Williams
Charles
J.K. Simmons
Matt "The Bat" Hardesty
Amanda Peet
Jules James
Reina Hardesty
Beth
Ryan Lee
John Elton
Angela Relucio
Floribeth's Aunt
Adelle Drahos
Podcast Superfan
Sean Goulding
Hungry Fan
Joshua Hoover
Fatty Bombalatty
Thomas Hughes
Smoking Fracker Player
David Iwanicki
Bombalatty Brother
Glenn Walkup
Butler 3rd Base Coach
Sarah Eliza Argens
Food Ciry Girl #2
Perry Johnson
Bar Patron
Lilly Roberson
Cindy
Keisuke Hoashi
Translator
Ruben Bugayong
Slap Boxing Friend
Scot Reddy
Butler Fan
Haji Abdullah
Large Man
John Atwood
Bill Douglas
Aina Dumlao
Diwata Cruz
Matt Mercurio
Wacky Auctioneer
Allie McCulloch
Female Brock-Head
Vince Pisani
Male Brock-Head
Ira Glass
Jeremy Madden
Annoying Selfie Fan
Dan McDonough
Hipster
Ron Perkins
Abortion Doctor
Heather Ayers
Diana
Ross Marquand
Brockmire's Father
Rich Eisen
Brian F. Durkin
Robbie Butler
Shane Donovan Lewis
BBQ Boy / Lil Pete
Michael Koske
Ticket Taker / Barons Fan / Concession Stand Worker
Brian Kenny
Jonah Keri
Tim Kurkjian
Kenny Mayne
Dan Patrick
Steve Coulter
Coach Pom Pom
Toby Huss
Johnny the Hat
Alex Phipps
Ryan Stanton
Paul Rae
Dale
Adan Rocha
Danny Cruz
Daisuke Tsuji
Yoshi Takatsu
David Walton
Gary
Molly Ephraim
Bartender
Ethan Daniels
Bat Boy Calhoun
Marc Demeter
Fracker Fan
Destiny Lopez
Pub Girl
Al Mitchell
Umpire
Melanie Loren
Chantal
Todd Davis
Avery E. King
Festival Fan
Kimrie Lewis
Bobbi
Clifton Powell
Charles Sr.
Adam Drescher
Stadium Manager
Paul Brian Johnson
Terry
Elizabeth Youman
Charlie
Zamani Wilder
Charlynn Richmond
Hakim Callender
Damon
Ted Huckabee
Leland
Spectator
Benjamin Weaver
Lindsay Ayliffe
Minister
Jef Holbrook
Nephew Jim
Jeff K. Lester
Selfie Guy
Greg Puckett
Funeral Attendant
Valerie Jane Parker
Groupie
Duran Butler
Waiter
Dreama Walker
Whitney
Tracey Bonner
Cassie
Jamie Dion
Garrett
Hemky Madera
Pedro Uribe
Utkarsh Ambudkar
Raj
Travon Mcfarland
Two Hands
Sarah Blackman
Nicole
Jared Simon
Doctor #1
Mary Kraft
Chastity / Sam
Selena Anduze
Doctor #2
Sydney Wease
Mascot
Anthony B. Harris
Medical Intern
Wesley Kuykendoll
Rick
Carrie Preston
Elle
Joe Knezevich
Greg
Matt Myers
Patient
Adriyan Rae
Yvonne
Drew Starkey
Brad Christie
Jimi Kocina
Donald Ray Arnold
Brittany Kelly
Waitress
John Scarvey
Oakland Fan
Kodai Yamaguchi
Baseball Fan
George Brett
Lauren Halperin
Receptionist
Frank Brennan
Mr. Benjamin
Ryan Vo
Holy Shit Guy
Michael D'Elia
Bissette Williams
Gamer Girl
Bob Costas
Dan Castellaneta
Duke Yipkowski (voice)
Linda Lavin
Lorraine
Justin Miles
Courtney Sauls
Gabby's Partner / Gayle
Thomas DuPont
Charles Green
Norman Glasscock
Robert Tinsley
Oakland A's Baseball Player (uncredited)
Quinn Cooke
Denise
Michele Jang
Dakota
Ginger Curl
Pat
Jordan Iacovella
Young Jim
Natalie Renee Long
Young Lucy
Andrea Maiuro
Doctor
Becky Ann Baker
Jean Brockmire Glasscock
Phil Reeves
Art Newlie
Martha Plimpton
Shirley
Richard Kind
Gus Barton
Christine Woods
Maggie Nickols
Christian Robinson
Dave / Dave (uncredited)
Travis James
Newlie Fan #2
Cole Nowacki
Newlie Fan #1
Holden Scott
Jared
Jay DeVon Johnson
Moderator
Suehyla El-Attar Young
Kansas City Royals Staff Member
Aria Que
Young Floribeth
Matt Markopoulos
Military Guard
Vanessa Padla
Manila Pedestrian
Peg O'Keef
Spry Grandma
Jonathon Pawlowski
Reporter
Benny Thrasher
Brad
Jacob Wilhelmi
Bad Grandson
David Sullivan
Rusty
Alana Cavanaugh
Young Jules
Rebecca Koon
Carol
Cliff Weissman
The Great Tomás
John Ales
New York Yankees Owner
Michael Bunin
Leslie
Lynne Ashe
Human Resources Manager
J. LaRose
Chief Sango Whitehorse
Ron Clinton Smith
Freddie
Dominic Cancelliere
Lil' Diazepam
Julian B Lin
Stadium Employee
Ruben Vidal
Colonizers #22
David Pressman
Orion
Brigitte Bidet
Dolly
Kitana Goyena
Teenage Beth
Ilmer Osorio
Cult Leader
Joe Buck
Valerie Azlynn
Janet
Matt Levin
Man
Jassey Kris Hilotin
Eden
Kevin Patrick Murphy
Limòn Stranger
Ashley Uecker
Hall of Fame attendee
Eric Wilkerson
Hall of Fame VIP
Paul F. Tompkins
Harold K. Finnegan
Aaron Gillespie
Benny Rodriguez
Katie Finneran
Lucy Brockmire
Victoria Blade
Limòn / Debbie / Limòn
Ego Nwodim
Liz
Andrew Hill Newman
Dr. Barrett
Fray Forde
'Symphony' Pitchman
Charity Hitchcock
Lennox
Haroon Khan
Confused Teenager
Andrea Laing
Bernice
Ivana J. Lewis
Jasper
Mason Pike
Pedestrian
Jack Marino
Barfly
David Silverman
Dylan's Dad