Full cast (27)
Jeffrey Dean Morgan
Self - Host
Allyson “Ally” Bross
Self - Contestant
Christian “Biggy” Bailey
Jonah Evarts
Contestant
Josh Martínez
Kim Conner
Mack Fitzgerald
Rachel Rossette
Rick Szabo
Shayne Cureton
Tai Lowry
JaNa Craig
Peter Weber
Heidi Klum
Self - Guest
Dan Gheesling
Wendell Holland
Kaylor Martin
Tiffany Mitchell
Aesha Scott
Nicolas Vansteenberghe
Will Anderson
Lauren Barnwell
Amun Cosme
Lacy Dollar
Matthew Gaston
Dalen Michaels
Sasha Alex Sloan