Full cast (124)
Hailee Steinfeld
Emily Dickinson
Toby Huss
Edward Dickinson
Adrian Enscoe
Austin Dickinson
Anna Baryshnikov
Lavinia 'Vinnie' Dickinson
Ella Hunt
Sue Gilbert
Amanda Warren
Betty
Chinaza Uche
Henry
Jane Krakowski
Mrs. Dickinson
Gus Halper
Joseph Lyman
Matt Lauria
Ben Newton
Jason Mantzoukas
Bee (voice)
Warren Katz
Minister
John Mulaney
Henry David Thoreau
James Urbaniak
Ophthalmologist
Emilio Oliveira
Loud Man
Anna O'Donoghue
Loud Woman
Brendan Hayes
Dishwasher Vendor
Olivia Khoshatefeh
Young Woman #1
Manuela Sosa
Young Woman #2
Timothy Simons
Frederick Law Olmsted
Jibz Cameron
Sanford Robinson Gifford
Kelli Barrett
Adelaide May
Curtis Bannister
Opera Chorus Member 1
Lindsay Nicole Chambers
Opera Chorus Member 2
Ron Crawford
Usher
Jessica Hecht
Aunt Lavinia
Jen Ponton
Body Healer
Nick Kroll
Edgar Allan Poe
Ade Otukoya
Henry 'Box' Brown
Omar Shaukat
Townie 1
Tim Simon
Townie 2
Braeden Brickner
Newspaper Boy
Tatiana Marie Barber
Activist / Dancer
Anthony Auguste
Dancer
Teddy Bergman
Minister / Daniel Bliss
Kenny Bermudez
Chloe Campbell
Shawn Alynda Fisher
Marquis Floyd
Antonio Harvey
Marley Lubin
Nerita McFarlane
Bethany Puente
Wade Watson
Imani Wisdom
Damani Van Rensalier
Marié Botha
Mary Bowles
Brendan Dalton
Sylvester
Finn Jones
Samuel Bowles
Pico Alexander
Henry 'Ship' Shipley
Ayo Edebiri
Hattie
David Manis
Roland Sands
Old Man
Gus Birney
Jane Humphrey
Dewight Braxton Jr.
Soldier
Justine Rappaport
Puppeteer
Billy Eichner
Walt Whitman
Zosia Mamet
Louisa May Alcott
Beth Ditto
Pfaff's Dancer
James Michael Lambert
Bloody Stump
Anthony R. Mottola
Wounded Soldier
Mariah Naomi Sanchez
Nurse
Wale Adebiyi
Orderly
Emily Kramm
Pfaff's Dancer #1
Markcus Blair
Pfaff's Dancer #2
Julio Rey
Pfaff's Dancer #3
Daphne Kinard
Pfaff's Dancer #4
Zo Tipp
Pfaff's Dancer #5
Gabriel Hyman
Pfaff's Dancer #6
Tómas Matos
Pfaff's Dancer #7
Emily Dorsch
Auctioneer
Nandita Shenoy
Woman
Bex Odorisio
Woman 1
Will Pullen
Nobody / Frazar Stearns
Ryah Nixon
Woman 2
David Michael Garry
Man in Crowd
Jordan Bellow
Soldier #2
Jordan Lage
Asylum Head Doctor
Marceline Hugot
Asylum Patient
Annie Hamilton
Florence
Morgan Sullivan
Casey Jane Ellison
Doll Woman
Sibyl Santiago
Alexio Barboza
Ziwe
Sojourner Truth
Chloe Fineman
Sylvia Plath
Jamel Davall Rodriguez
Freddie
Tuck Sweeney
Irish Man / Bartender
Samuel Farnsworth
George Gould
Kevin Yee
Toshiaki
Sophie Zucker
Abby Wood
Robert Picardo
Ithamar Conkey
Wiz Khalifa
Death
Allegra Heart
Abiah Root
Darlene Hunt
Maggie
Erin Gerasimovich
Anna
Neville Lee
Clara
Joey Odom
Archibald
Max Chernin
Samuel Strong
Levi Ricks
Helen
Gabriel Ebert
Thomas Wentworth Higginson
Nore Davis
Solomon
Myles Alexander Evans
Erasmus
Tristan Griffin
Everett
Wavyy Jonez
The Wall
Curt Morlaye
Michael River Jordan
Mirella Cardoso
Mermaid #1
Imani Pearl Williams
Mermaid #2
Chinara Stroman
Mermaid #3
Kathy Liu
Mermaid #4
Natalie Von Kirk
Mermaid #5
Jeremy Lawrence
Professor Hitchcock
James Dwyer
Prefect
Peggy Cosgrave
Mrs. Thoreau
Abra Tabak
Thoreau's Sister
Vince Edgehill
Conductor
Lucas Near-Verbrugghe
James
Michael Braun
Thomas Elliott Moody
Peter Maloney
Doctor Brewster
John Leonard Thompson
Mr. Humphrey
Dee Hoty
Mrs. Humphrey
Andre Urban
Sailor
Jason Williams
Dasha Nekrasova
Ellen Mandeville Grout