Full cast (133)
Keegan-Michael Key
Josh Skinner
Cecily Strong
Melissa Gimble
Fred Armisen
Reverend Howard Layton
Dove Cameron
Betsy McDonough / Jenny Banks
Alan Cumming
Mayor Aloysius Menlove / Dooley Blight
Kristin Chenoweth
Miss Codwell / Mildred Layton
Aaron Tveit
Danny Bailey / Topher
Jaime Camil
Doc Jorge Lopez / Sergeant Rivera
Ariana DeBose
Emma Tate / Emcee
Ann Harada
Florence Menlove / Madam Frau
Peppermint
Madam Vina
Timothy Webber
Marv
David Adams
Corn Puddin' Cook
Jason Burkart
Buford Riggs
Stephanie Cho
Waitress
Thomas Wayne Hum
Husband Ted
Levi McCachen
Like Minded Guy
Iris Quinn
Joanna
Nikolai Witschl
Undertaker
Leana Yu
Birthing Woman Holly
Style Dayne
DJ
Kyra Leroux
Carrie
Whitney Lykins
Bridesmaid
Rryla McIntosh
Bride
Astrid Trueman
Nellie
Emma Pedersen
Young Woman #2
Viola Abley
Freckle-Faced Girl
Nolen Dubuc
Buck-Toothed Boy
Ridley Havok McLeod
Wild Hair Boy
Pedro Salvín
Old Doc Lopez
Peyton Amelia Feltham
Tap Dancer / Choir
Anthony Juo
Choir / Tap Dancer
Ema Lake
Inca Scott
Tap Dancer
Jenna Lamb
Alisa Lymar
Leah Park
Matias Wong
Dolores Drake
Biddy #1
Eileen Barrett
Biddy #2
Sarah Hayward
Helen
Martin Short
Steve the Leprechaun / Oscar the Leprechaun
Liam Quiring-Nkindi
Carson
Garfield Wilson
Henry the Iceman
Michelle Rios
Mrs. Lopez
Alex Barima
Freddy
Cassandra Consiglio
Nancy
Jak Barradell
Core Dancer
Daniel Bernardo
Amanda Cleghorn
Alex Gullason
Alex / Young Woman #1
Sarah Formosa
Julio Fuentes
Tristan Chad Ghostkeeper
Julia Harnett
Shelley Stewart Hunt
Jessica Keeling
Jared Khalifa
Troy Mclaughlin
Gray Monczka
Kevin McNulty
Farmer McDonough / Father Flanagan
Matt Nethersole
Serena Crouse
Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl Annie
Derek Piquette
Ashley Brooke St. John
Ericka Hunter
Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl Molly
Sam Strasfeld
Warren Yang
Marina Lazzaretto
Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl
Jane Krakowski
Bobby Flanagan / Countess Gabriele Von Blerkom
Tituss Burgess
Narrator
Darcey Johnson
Innkeeper Harvey / Reporter
Scott Patey
Larry the Fireman / Reporter
Patrick Page
Octavius Kratt
Bijou Brattston
Tootie McDonough / Orphan Dancer
Immanuel Chibota
Newsie
Felice Kakaletris
Little Girl
Yvette Lu
Fertility Doctor
Jessica Vosk
Little Girl's Mother
Arielle Tuliao
Barfly Singer / Woman #3
Sandy Robson
Angry Dad
Patti Allan
Mrs. Silwinski
Joshua Harding
Josh's Patient
Isabel Birch
Little Orphan
Michael Delleva
Michael
Lee Shan Gibson
Cop
Caitriona Murphy
Core Dancer / Court Observer
Holly Arthur
Phillip Joseph Steward
Kairo Ellis
Orphan
Marisa Gold
Marisa
Amitai Marmorstein
Pete the Milkman / Skeet the Juror / Skeet the Hot Dog Man
Willow Rose Walker
Young Melissa
Josh St. John
Karin Konoval
Female Barfly / Female Barfly (voice)
Matt Afonso
Robber Prisoner
Justin Stone
Conrad Prisoner
Milana Wan
Orphan / Orphan Dancer
Kris Grzella
Tribal Dancer / Core Dancer / Jail Dancer
Steeven K.
Jazz Musician
Andrew Kyrzyk
Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer
Katrina Reynolds
Core Dancer / Court Observer / Backup Singer
Bianca Melchior
Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer / Kelly, Audition Dancer
Micaela Nyland
Priscilla, Audition Dancer
Shane Simpson
Core Dancer / Jail Dancer / Tribal Dancer
Alex Wong
Mark Logtenberg
Killer Prisoner
Michael Q. Adams
Advisor
David Beairsto
Gerry South
Judge
Jennie Ford
Court Stenographer
Justine Gera
Tribal Dancer / Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl Elsie Vale
Sharona D'Ornellas
Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer / Cabaret Girl Pepper
Katherine Gayle
Tribal Dancer / Cabaret Girl / Core Dancer
Ellexis Wejr
Orphan Dancer
Alice Comer
Tiny Tap Dancer
Aletheia Berry
Jacob Ian Dalzell
Haven Gin
Joy Lho
Ayla McMillan
Noah Park
Lincoln Russo
Anya-Shae Johnson
Cole Sivertson
Khamisa Wilsher
Barfly Singer
Tanya Jade
Jacqueline Robbins
Bernstein Sister
Joyce Robbins
Ella Wejr
Dance Orphan #3 / Orphan Dancer
Felicia Simone
Backup Singer
Siera Staples
Sarah Cantuba
New Narrator