Full cast (53)
Robert Kazinsky
Jimmy Pritchard
Tim DeKay
Duval Pritchard
Dilshad Vadsaria
Mary Goodwin
Adhir Kalyan
Otto Goodwin
Scott Menville
Arthur (voice)
Philip Baker Hall
Jimmy Pritchard (75 years old)
Ciara Bravo
Gracie Pritchard
Vanessa Lengies
Alexa
Joseph Gatt
Caleb
Dean Redman
C.O. Biggs
Alison Araya
Gloria
Diana Bang
Emma
Adam DiMarco
Asher Davis
Adan Canto
Connor Graff
Adam Dietrich
Jittery Burglar
Preston Vanderslice
Malcolm Sprague
Donny Lucas
FBI Agent #1
Natalie Grace
Kelly Crane
Alex Rose
Cranston
David Jacox
Finch
Sean Carey
Dr. Pearson
Steve Baran
Garodnick
Jeff Gladstone
Stritzke
Kevin Mundy
FBI Agent Grigs
Mark Gash
Dr. Lee
Jason Bempong
ER Nurse
Erin Cebula
News Anchor
Chris Cope
Jimmy Pritchard (young)
Michael Meneer
Reporter
Piers Morgan
Derek Webster
Agent Strayburn
Nicky Whelan
Bettina
John McIntosh
Agent Bech
Jason Douglas
FBI Interviewer
Jason Skeen
Jimmy Pritchard (in 1985)
Daniel Buran
Jasper
Michael J Rogers
Mellenburg
Francis X. McCarthy
George
Breckin Meyer
Wally Luskin
Carmen Moore
Agent Sue Adair
Stephen Spender
Carson
Trevor Carroll
Benji
Jia Bains
Mary Goodwin (Age 7)
Amaree Samnani
Otto Goodwin (Age 7)
Parm Soor
Father Goodwin
Camillia Mahal
Mother Goodwin
Yvonne Chapman
Tammy
Gerry Rousseau
Judge
Boyan Vukelic
Car Owner
David Lyle
Peng's Bartender
Amanda Detmer
Helen Pritchard
Troy Rudolph
SWAT Commander (uncredited)
Kennedi Clements
Lisa