Full cast (171)
Taran Killam
Will
Leighton Meester
Angie
Kimrie Lewis
Poppy
Jake Choi
Miggy
Brad Garrett
Douglas
Marlow Barkley
Sophie
Tyler Wladis
Graham
Devin Trey Campbell
Rory
Mia Allan
Emma Fogerty
Ella Allan
Amy Fogerty
Brent Alan Henry
Cop
Monique Lea-Gall
Ali Ghandour
Raj
David Theune
Gerald
Heather Wynters
Organ Player
Cameron Crovetti
Carol
Al Madrigal
Rick
Gee Alexander
Shirtless Man (as Gee Alexander)
Kylia Ramos
Cha-Cha
Kaitlin Yamano
Dancer Girl #1
Jasmine Sison
Dancer Girl #2
Lily Liquigan
Dancer Girl #3
Alden Rosaldo
Dancer Boy #1
Jackie Seiden
Jackie / Eleanor
Julian Torres
Dancer Boy #2
Cash Ramirez
Dancer Boy #3
Ryan Alvarez
Terry
Lindsey Gort
Judith
George Kareman
Glen
Hannah Simone
Dr. Monica Dewan
Talia Toms
Molly
Camille Chen
Lex
Naomi Ekperigin
Miss Adams
Vanessa Bayer
Mia
Nicole Randall Johnson
Dr. Rhonda
Alice Wetterlund
Nora
Chris Harrison
Timothy Hornor
Phil
Joe Wengert
Jared
Bashir Salahuddin
Ron
Chloe Perrin
Zoe
Rhys Darby
Dr. Biscuits
Christopher Chen
Gil
Andy Favreau
Owen
Steve Zissis
Mark Rush
Allison Dunbar
Charlene
Kathleen Rose Perkins
Bobbi Babsen
Susan Yeagley
Barbara
Ali Chen
Deb
Hayes MacArthur
Xander Fogerty
Helen Slayton-Hughes
Diana
Ashley Wood
Joanna
Carrie Barrett
Kerry
Dhruv Uday Singh
Coach Floyd
Katrina Begin
Janice
John Michael Higgins
Bud Cooper
Mo Collins
Lucy Cooper
Sarah Yarkin
Homily Pronstroller
Ivy Schur
Louisa
Laci Mosley
Sharon
Patricia Belcher
Vice Principal Sara Yarble
Nick Hargrove
Brian
Lamar Woods
Dwayne
D'Arcy Carden
Kay
Rebecca Creskoff
Big Red
Patrick Birkett
Tony
Quinta Brunson
Bess
Carla Jimenez
Lil
Lauren Weedman
Franny
Jama Williamson
Tracy Freeze
Pam Murphy
Stacy
Steve Tom
Guy McCormick
Chris Geere
Colin
Tate Birchmore
Percy
Lance Bass
Adam Brody
Derek
Denny Siegel
Crystal
Ayden Mayeri
Heather
Christopher Jefferson
Diego
Adam Kang
Ty
P.L. Brown
Delivery Guy
Zeke Nicholson
Theo
Ajay Vidure
Doctor
Suzanne Gutierrez
Nurse
Jeff Holman
Mr. Withers
Keeshan Giles
Dad
Hans Holsen
Young Dad
Rachael Drummond
Carol's Mom
Serena Laney
Troy Ian Hall
Musician
Jason Medwin
Elando Baltimore
Hot Bartender
Ayinde Howell
Richard
Sai Lang
School Photographer
Ashleigh Crystal Hairston
Photographer
Chip O'Neil
Joe
Joy McElveen
Brenda
Welton Pitchford
Stage Manager
Frank Gerrish
Janitor Henderson
Kara Royster
KBS
David S. Robinson Hicks
Beer Pong Kid
Stephen Simon
Travis
Caleb Dolden
Alex
Denisse Ojeda
Jan
Casey Adams
Bo
Kale Clauson
Beck Call Chum
Angela Gulner
Trish the Barista
J.Stephen Brantley
Goat Guy
Navaris Darson
Man at the Counter
Rocco Risoli
Rocco
Alana Duqum
Loraine
Laticia Rolle
Cathy
Dean Sharpe
Gus
Keanu Beausier
Waiter
Sisa Grey
Jane
Lincoln Lilhanand
Baby Jack
Theodore Lilhanand
Danny Gura
Gabe
Richelle Meiss
Jen
Lynette DuPree
Joyce
Meghann Murphy
Kammy
Stephanie Y. Wang
Marsha
Chase Kim
Kevin
Luca Sammarcelli
Sunscreen Kid
Indiana Massara
Britney
Loretta Shenosky
Polish Aunt
Marius Biegai
Polish Uncle
Lucia Fasano
Employee
Jake Ynzunza
Orderly
Taneka Johnson
Boone Nelson
Little Boy
Liam Risinger
Joryian Bates
Teen
Doran Butler
Pizza Guy
Cosme Flores
Carole Wells
Cassandra
Connor Gibbs
Teenage Roller Worker
Robert Paterno
Employee Steve
Eddiejames 'EJ' Castro
Tween Douglas
Jonas Garvin
Noah Segan
Warren
Connie Jackson
Betty
Ervin Ross
TJ
Jesse James D'Angelo
Barista
Helen Madelyn Kim
Hostess
Sarah Beth Bassak
Co-Worker
Michael Boucher
Audience Member
Tyler Cameron
Danny
Cade Michael
Franklin
Ethan Sandler
Ethan
Shaw Purnell
Dolores
Akrosia Samson
Woman
Carolyne Maraghi
Deb Schwepps
Roy Allen III
Judge
Alan Ehrlich
Man
Quinn O'Malley
Taylor
Jarod Bainbridge
Louis
Remy Ortiz
Claw Machine Man
Regis Philbin
Lissa Danshaw
Vegas Nurse
Jeremiah Caleb
Robyn Okrant
OB-GYN
Frank Brantley
Dealer
Hermione Lynch
Priscilla
Carlos Linares
Hidalgo
Peter Spruyt
Docent
James O'Halloran
Brian Francisco Molina
Jared T.
Travis DesLaurier
Dave
Newman Wolf
Innkeep Josh
Miles Burris
Jared R.