Full cast (42)
Josh Groban
Tony Caruso Jr.
Tony Danza
Tony Caruso Sr.
Monica Barbaro
Cora Vasquez
Isiah Whitlock Jr.
Burl Loomis
Bill Kottkamp
Ryan Domki
Rebecca Rittenhouse
Macy Clark
Connor Tillman
Deputy Tillman
Emma Ishta
Belinda Mannix
Christopher James Baker
Teddy Coluca
Andrew Dolan
Alanna Ubach
Joe Holt
Aaron Serotsky
Chaka DeSilva
Bob Saget
Andy Grotelueschen
Billy Malone
Sergeant Chet Finch
Orfeh
Donna Livingston
Victor Cruz
Sergeant Rudner
John Scurti
Wendell Kirk
John Carroll Lynch
Sherman Smalls
David Furr
Margo Seibert
Matthew Saldivar
C. Thomas Howell
Joy Suprano
Jocelyn
Glenn Fitzgerald
Brooke Langton
Edward Carnevale
Frank Whaley
Dan Byrd
Donovan Demark
Caroline Aaron
Alice Spivak
Molly Price
Captain
Alyssa Cheatham
Young girl
Ann Mahoney
Phyllis / Phillis
Lynn Marocola
NYPD (uncredited)
Alexander Flores
Stork
Alex Webb
Inspector Quinn
Mattea Conforti
Young Niece
Sedly Bloomfield
Landlord