Full cast (239)
Geoff Pierson
Jack Malloy
Stephanie Hodge
Jennie Malloy
Kevin Connolly
Ryan Malloy
Nikki Cox
Tiffany Malloy
Justin Berfield
Ross Malloy
Wendy Benson-Landes
Barbara Caufield
Joyce Van Patten
Maureen Slattery
Bobcat Goldthwait
Mr. Floppy (voice)
Allan Trautman
Mr. Floppy (puppeteer)
Hayden Panettiere
Little Girl
Kristanna Loken
Sable O'Brian
Aimee Warren
Twin #1
Danielle Warren
Twin #2
Michael Dubrow
Buzzcut Guy
Jessica Hahn
Miss Taylor
Dana Daurey
Amber
Brett Stimely
Larry
Ant
Barry
David O'Donnell
Chuck
Steven Gilborn
Doctor
Betsy Monroe
Nurse Crenshaw
Thomas Myers
TV Evangelist (voice)
Stephen Kay
Salesman
Tommy Bertelsen
Little Ryan
Marnette Patterson
Cindy
Quinn Duffy
Matt Cochran
Shonda Whipple
Chelsea / Angora
James Cooper
Gavin
Nicole Nagel
Amazon Woman
Andrea Bendewald
TV Newscaster
Momo Kimura
Japanese Kid
Dustin Voigt
Preppie Guy
Jamie Kennedy
Stoney / Pony Burger Attendant (voice)
Victoria Jackson
Susan
Diane Delano
Vic
Ian Patrick Williams
Ray Paul Jones
Sandy Sprung
Motel Manager
Elisabeth Harnois
Patty
Dawn Landon
JJ
Scott Matthew Bloom
Football Player
Donna D'Errico
Fantasy Girl #1
Kristen Williams
Fantasy Girl #2
Richard Hoyt-Miller
Mailman Pops
Darcy Lee
French Teacher
Will Dimpflmaier
Mike
Kevin Scannell
Chipper Collins
Jeff Doucette
Coach
Gary Coleman
Devil
Edmund L. Shaff
Insurance Guy
Craig Kvinsland
Jim
Judy Kain
Meter Maid
Eric Menyuk
Policeman
Murray Rubinstein
Guard
Donald Gibb
Spike
Blake Soper
Stoney / Billy Emery
Gunther Jensen
Murderer
Mila Kunis
Chloe
Samantha Esteban
Cute Girl
Riki Rachtman
Riki Rachtman (voice)
John Patrick White
Danny
Priscilla Maye
Abbie
Michael Warwick
Gordy / Nerd Boy
Gregory Polcyn
Lizard Agent
Kent Irwin
Pierre
Diane Farr
Michelle
Jackée Harry
Ms. Blake
J. Robin Miller
Agnes
Aquilina Soriano
Sushi
Lisa Malkiewicz
Crystal
Samantha Levitt
Amanda
Joshua Levey
Eugene
Joel Michaely
Paul
Seann William Scott
Moondoggie
Allen Scotti
Louie Louie
John D. Beck
John
Benjamin Shelfer
Beau / Guy / Johnny / Bullhorn (voice) / Pizza Boy
Kenneth Kimmins
Dean
Nick Toth
Quigley
Tom Myers
Reporter / Physics Teacher / Man / TV Detective (voice)
Adam Kaiz
Charles
Maggie Lawson
Madolyn
Tracy Scoggins
Morgana
Pat Crawford Brown
Sadie Glickstein
George Schirmann
Bingo Caller
Jennifer Banko
Natasha Dorfhuber
R.D. Robb
Bernie
Marissa Leigh
Aaron Lustig
Maitre D'
Daniel Markel
Guy Babone
Erik Estrada
David Jahn
Rose Seller Guy
Tom Perna
Dr. Dibitetto
Melanie Good
Pretty Girl
Kimerlee Curyl
Girl
Melody Clarke
Daughter
Bridgette Anderson
Drew
Eliza Sroka-Benisty
Galina
Debra Mooney
Saleslady
Connie Sawyer
Old Woman
Edd Byrnes
Fossily
Fran Solomita
Herbie Sternberg
Doug Jones
Boomer
Karen Moncrieff
Zelda
Johnny Venokur
Maury
Christopher Kracker
Bobby / Messenger
Derek Sellers
Valet / Dr. Lifowitz / Umpire / Delivery Guy
Joel Berti
Johnny Stompanoto
Mary Gillis
Mrs. Garbaggio
Tony Radev
Delivery Boy
Jim Ward
TV Announcer (voice)
Oliver Muirhead
Mr. Monteleone
Maryann Rozsas
Nurse
Sarah Lancaster
Alice
Patrick Mickler
Cop
Ivana Miličević
Oksana
Richard Vidan
Boris
Dale Raoul
Granny Goodness
Kevin Light
Prince
SW Fisher
Male Customer
Scott Gurney
Dean Valentine / Chip
Jeannie Elias
Goldie
Jessie Jones
Mrs. Lupkin
Peggy Miley
Mrs. Dempsey
Scott Lipscomb
Brad
Jamie Anderson
Carla
Jennifer Lyons
Erica
Tom Byrd
Professor Alfred
Joe De Cenzo
Messenger
Deborah Kellner
Muffy
Michael Houston King
Chad
Natalia Cigliuti
Francesca
Kevin Curran
Crazy Lou
Jean Speegle Howard
Miss Mugglesworth / Mrs. McGillicuddy / Mrs. Lewcowitz / Miss Neezballs
J. Stewart Burns
Elmo / J. Stewart Burns / Singing Stuffed Animal (voice)
Karen Lynn Scott
Marilyn
Don Novello
Guy Macaroon / Father Guido Sarducci
Jordan Levin
Jelene Daney
Mindy
Ed O'Bannon
Eric Tecosky
Joey
Matthew Cox
Joey / Boy / Scream Masked Kid
Bridget Flanery
Bunny
David Youse
Skip
Thomas Rosales Jr.
Pablo
Seth Jaffe
FBI Guy #2
Krissy Carlson
Cookie
Marcus H. Nelson
Guy
Faith Minton
Bertha
Constance Zimmer
LaVerne
Megan McKinley
Kimmy
Jack Brewer
Desmond
Jenna Von Oÿ
Bitsy
Tony V.
Sal / David Mandel
Lisa Arturo
Robin Berry
Jane
Brogan Roche
Dick
Suanne Spoke
Ms. Musante / Prudish Woman
Richard Sanders
Mr. Peabody
Jonathan Aube
Ernest Liu
Lee
Shirlee Elliot
Holly
Elizabeth Tatus
Cricket
Alicia Rickter
John Nimo
Old Jack
Dawn Fine
Singing Ballerina Clock (voice) / Secretary
Rhonda Shear
Beggar Spice
Nick Cornish
Billy
Ashley Buccille
Girl #2
Jennifer Lynn Grosso
Older Kitty
Chris L. McKenna
Mikey
Dan Ponce
Chicky
Linda O'Neil
Pat Brymer
Dinosaur (voice)
Christina Lynch
Singing Stuffed Animal (voice)
Marcy Vosburgh
Christina Moore
Cherri
Kimberly J. Brown
Helena / Girl #1
Vanessa Guild
Vanilla
Kiva Dawson
Caitlin Blackpoole
Arturo Gil
Dancing Baby
Brighton Hertford
Kitty / Girl
Tom Kenny
J. Cyril Studebaker
John Ziaukas
Steve Lookner
Kromar
Johnnie Colter
Henry
Ossie Mair
Janitor
Gretchen Morgan
Valerie
Peggy Jo Jacobs
Shulie Cowen
Ann
Paul Popowich
Jerome
Jennifer Hale
Kobe
Denney Pierce
Obnoxious Guy #2
Chris Durand
Obnoxious Guy #3
Faith Salie
Caitlin
Alex Nesic
Jacques
Kamala Dexter
Beth / Kami
Shepard T. Ross
Guy #2
Michael Hitchcock
Coach McNiff
Robert Anderson
Coach Vosburgh
Tamara Braun
Nell / Lacy
Danielle Weeks
Liz / Jennifer
Aubry Fisher
Sarah
James Wong Jim
Yahuda
Linda Kim
Zipporah
Thomas DeWier
Awkie
Ryan Holihan
Elliott
Mary Greenwood
Spice / Nancy / Girl
Jennifer Lothrop
Penny
Matthew Blashaw
Rusty
David Pressman
Tony
Zach Chapman
Umlaut / Nazi
Charles Howerton
Danica Sheridan
Security Guard
Astrid Rossol
Girl #1
Jamie Flowers
Taffy
Drew Hayes
Tom
Kato Kaelin
Smoking Teacher / Happy Bender
Rob Leo Roy
Mr. Gutman
Danielle Keaton
Young Girl
Gerry Cohen
M. Cohen
Orlando Woolridge
Karl
Bob Glouberman
Dr. J
Kyle Sullivan
David
Mikyla Archibald
Woman
Calvin Remsberg
Pavarotti
Alley Baggett
David Faustino
Jimbo
Victoria Silvstedt
Brandi
Lou Briseno
Juan
Felipe Delarosa
Eduardo
John Ducey
Tasha Goldthwait
Christa Campbell
Kirsten
Matt Reid
Handsome Guy #1
Jeffrey Castillo
Handsome Guy #2
Wendie Jo Sperber
Ms. Snaylops
Chelsea Lynn
Little Tiffany
Frank Lloyd
Policeman / Righty / Security Guard / Guard / Mr. Bassilli / Closet Monster / Manager / Hunter / White-Coated Man / Abominable Snowman / Lefty / Teeth McKenzie / Rico / Cop / FBI Guy #1 / Guy #1 / Joe / Obnoxious Guy #1 / Mad Janitor