Full cast (50)
Vic Michaelis
Ify Nwadiwe
Denzel
Josh Ruben
Kepl / Dr. Milk
Brian David Gilbert
Professor Avery "Jerry" Goodman
Oscar Montoya
Jasper Sheffield Wednesday V
Jiavani
Casper Sheffield Wednesday V
Ally Beardsley
Pig #2
Rashawn Nadine Scott
Martha Tops
Ross Bryant
Lucian Azathoth
Kimia Behpoornia
Fourth Witch / Marionette Conqui
Sam Reich
Sam Reich (uncredited)
Tamar Levine
Self
Bruce Spaulding Fuller
Isabella Roland
Leighanna-Jean Gruthers / Charlotte Excitement
Jacob Wysocki
Zonton de la Doll / Hayes Steele / Ollie
Chris Redd
Jukebox
Talia Tabin
Bianca
Anna Garcia
Zeke Aaron McKinley / Princess Emily / J.W. Smokes / Princess Emily (archive voice) (uncredited)
Kate Berlant
Barbara
Zac Oyama
Tommy Shriggly / Phoenix / Dash Highland
John Early
Bill
Lisa Gilroy
Spencer / Nana "Vic's Ex Step-Grandmother" / Oops Lil Fart
Danielle Pinnock
Ta'Tania Jackson
Brennan Lee Mulligan
Augbert / Greg Excitement / Archimedes
Paul F. Tompkins
David Hoyle Jr.
Corin Wells
Steffi Pops
Bobby Moynihan
Dan Wesley Sharron
Echo Kellum
Jordache
Alex Song-Xia
Claude McCaw
Nicole Byer
Candice
Rekha Shankar
Mother Hot Dog
Wesley T. Jones
PA
Paul Robalino
Skyler DeMarco / Self / Phone Caller (voice)
Jeremy Culhane
Boris Tarshkokan
Caitlin Reilly
Stop
David Kerns
Self / Phone Caller (voice)
Angela Giarratana
Fanoli
Eugene Cordero
Sudzo / Frederick
Demi Adejuyigbe
Zinnia
Frankie Quiñones
Lil Huffy
Laci Mosley
Paloma
Katya Zamolodchikova
Linda Elizabeth Marie Braintree
Rachel Pegram
Diamond
Chelsea Peretti
Jane
Nate Miller
Alex Fernie
Therapist / Therapist / Phone Caller (voice)
Kate Elliott
Stop's Assistant
Eden Perry
1st Assistant Director
Keegan Hawk
Eve Hinz